Home Headphone Comparisons Sennheiser HD 380 vs. HD 558 | VERY DIFFERENT!

Sennheiser HD 380 vs. HD 558 | VERY DIFFERENT!

by Stuart Charles Black
Published: Last Updated on

Don't forget to share if you found it helpful!

Hi friend and Welcome to my humble abode!

Covering the Sennheiser HD 380 vs. HD 558 is going to be a lot of fun, largely because the 380 seems to be such a forgotten headphone. It doesn’t really get much attention at all. I know quite a bit about both though, and I’ll be doing an in-depth comparison of each for you!

So grab a snack, sit back and relax because…

You’ve come to the right place!!

What I will bring you in this review

of each headphone

  1. Specifications
  2. Summary
  3. Pros
  4. Cons
  5. Neutral
  6. Amp/DAC Requirements
  7. Who this headphone benefits?
  8. Consensus/Conclusion
  9. Similarities and Differences
  10. Final Word

Now without further ado, let’s get rolling!


** = Many people have commented on this

Sennheiser HD 380


price: check amazon! | check eBay!
Type: Closed back
Fit: Circumaural (Over/around the ear)
Impedance: 54 Ohms. What is Headphone Impedance?
Frequency response: 8Hz-27kHz
Material: Plastic, Pleather
Headband: Padded
Color: Black


The Sennheiser HD 380’s are a direct descendant from the HD 280s, which were an exceptional pair of closed-back reference headphones as well.

The 380s seem to improve upon a lot of the shortcomings of their younger brother. I’m not going to get into that too much, but it helps in describing them as a reference point regardless. The HD 380’s have angled ear-cups, a very comfortable fit, and pads that don’t touch the ears for added comfort. The build on these is also fantastic, and they utilize an even more analytical sound than their sibling. I had the 280’s once. The clamping force was like putting your head into a vice grip and then tightening it all the way. Lol. The 380s have a snug fit, but it isn’t as overpowering. Someone did say that wearing the 380’s is like having your head eaten by an alligator. Hm. Very interesting. Know that both are pretty tight.

Be aware that they don’t do particularly well with sound-stage, given that they are a closed-back model.

Bass wise, they give a lot more impact, but still, remain tight, focused, and accurate. The HD 280’s were an incredibly durable set but had some headband issues. The 380s improve on that aspect as well. The headband is more straightforward in its construction and doesn’t have any easily breakable parts.

Something that greatly benefits this headphone, in particular, is burn-in time. Some believe in it, some don’t, but after about 100 hours they may sound like totally new headphones to you (in the best way possible). They really open up and the clarity becomes crystal clear. A big plus with these is sound isolation. While not 100% noise-canceling, they still do an exceptional job of keeping sound out, while also making it so you can’t hear much going on around you.

They are mostly neutral headphones with a touch of warmth.


  • Stock cable and ear pads are replaceable.
  • **Construction. Very well built and should last a long time. A standard for all Sennheiser products really. They also fold quite nicely and aren’t nearly as heavy as the 280s.
  • Mid-range. This is probably the 380’s strongest attribute. The mids are slightly forward, which gives the sound a nice added energy to vocals and acoustics.
  • **Sound Isolation. These have been praised a lot in this regard. Not noise canceling, but about as close to it as it gets. Great for travel,  the office, and noisy environments in general.
  • Pretty flat and Neutral. These are pretty honest cans, which come in handy mixing in the studio. They do have a touch of warmth and are less neutral than the HD 280s.
  • Detail. Reveals some really nice subtlety and nuance to recordings that you may have missed in other headphones.


  • Ear cups. They will start to peel and shed after a while, not unlike the Sony MDR 7506’s. I have to say that was one of the things that drove me crazy about that headphone. The pieces got everywhere, including getting stuck in my ear! They are also prone to getting hot/sweaty after a while.


  • **Vice-grip. Some folks commented that the grip isn’t as bad as the HD 280s. Others said it was just as bad, if not worse! The clamping force is known to settle in over time, however.
  • Bass is generally tight, controlled, and accurate. It can get muddy in certain instances of high speed, or where it has to reach down farther than it’s comfortable doing. Some are saying this isn’t your typical Sennheiser sound, meaning the bass is a bit overdone. Still to many people there just isn’t enough of it, and what is there is very clean but unnoticeable.
  • **Respectable sound-stage. Not quite as open as a true open back, but not as closed off as say, The M50x. Surprisingly good for a closed-back model.
  • **Coiled cable. Does extremely well in the studio, not so much on the go. Luckily it is replaceable should you choose to go this route. A straight aftermarket cable is always an option.
  • Carrying Case. It’s nice that one is provided, but some say it’s much too small for these headphones with the added bulk of the cable. Who wants to have to force these in that tight of space?
  • **Unforgiving. This can be a good or bad thing depending on who you ask. If you want something analytical, these more than deliver. If you want to enjoy music from a variety of sources, you may be disappointed. They don’t do well with badly produced recordings. Think 128 kbps vs. 192 kbps. The higher the quality audio file the better. Lossless comes to mind here as sort of a benchmark.

Amp/DAC requirements

At 54 Ohms, it doesn’t need an amp. It isn’t known to bring out the sound all that much with the HD 380s. The overall effect is mostly just added volume. One or two people said it tightened the bass.

Who these headphones benefit?

They are kind of an all-around set. I’ve seen them endorsed for:

  • Metal
  • Rock
  • Pop
  • Classical
  • Techno
  • Rap/Hip-Hop


The HD 380’s are sort of a mixed bag. They are pretty neutral but do have some warmth. They are built solidly but have some issues with the ear-cup material. The vice-grip prevalent in the 280s is improved but still clamps pretty tight at first. Overall, their sound isolation is as close to noise-canceling as you’ll find, but they aren’t worth the asking price in the eyes of many.


The Sennheiser HD 558

  • price: Check amazon! | check eBay!
  • Type: Dynamic, open
  • Fit: Circumaural (over-ear)
  • Impedance: 50 ohms
  • Frequency response: 15 – 28,000 Hz
  • Material: Plastic, velour ear pads.
  • Color: Black


An open-backed model, the 558’s sport a tight bass response that knows its place. The sound only gets better the more you listen to them. With a revealing set of cans like these, you will start to notice a bad mixing job from a good one. They tend to excel at more laid-back music and struggle with aggressive, dense tunes. They do really well with classical and jazz. They do not particularly do well with rap/hip-hop, so buyers be warned. What they will make you do is sit back, close your eyes, and relax. A warmer, more beautiful sounding set.


  • Great clarity
  • Tight, smooth bass response
  • Neutral and balanced
  • Immersive music, movie, and gaming experience
  • *Extremely comfortable*
  • Comes with adapter
  • Lightweight and durable
  • Impressive sound-stage
  • Good channel separation (instruments can easily be picked out and listened to)
  • Replaceable cable


  • Chord is a bit long; can get tangled easily.
  • Clamp force will squeeze your dome piece when you first put them on. Takes a bit of time to get used to.
  • The 1/4″ to 3.5 mm adapter is awkward since usually, it’s the other way around.
  • A replacement chord must be purchased to avoid the inconvenience of the 1/4″ to 1/8″ adapter issue.

A secret to getting a better sound-stage and a bit of a punchier, more pronounced bass is modding them. The ear pads on both sides can be taken apart and a small piece of foam can then be removed. Check out this video on how to do it! Really easy! Some people say that doing this enables these headphones to sound identical to the HD 598, while others claim it does not at all. It does however make a difference in sound regardless…

My Foam Mod Tutorial

Let me know if you liked this type of video and what you would like to see in the future!

My Video Review!

Don’t forget to like, comment, and subscribe to my growing channel. I could really use your support!! 🙂

Amp/DAC requirements

At 50 Ohms, you’d be hard-pressed to find a sizeable difference with an amplifier. I say don’t bother. The most you’re probably going to get is a bit louder overall sound, but not enough to justify the cost.

Who these headphones benefit?

  1. These have been praised mightily for being very versatile. They do great with fps gaming, music, as well as movies. Also, there have been numerous nerds reporting that these things are great for CSGO. I had to look that up; it is the name of a game called “Counter-Strike: Global Offensive.” The sound-stage for gaming will knock your effing socks off, no joke. You will be able to tell where every sound is coming from with pinpoint precision and accuracy. Guy shooting at you from behind? 360 spin and WASTE HIM!
  2. They do well with laid-back genres like classical and jazz.
  3. They also do well with rock.
  4. They are very open and have an airy, laid-back sound. A beautiful sound.

What they aren’t good for

  1. They are not for bass heads. Please don’t buy these expecting to be blown away by the low end. The bass will however improve with time/burn-in.
  2. These are open-backed, and not for noise reduction or noise canceling. People will be able to hear what you are listening to at higher volumes. They are best suited in an isolated studio environment where you can really critique a mix or game out in your underwear. 😛


A really comfortable, versatile set of cans that handle a variety of applications such as gaming, music, and movies well. The cable however is a bit of a liability, and the 6.3 mm jack is a bit of an inconvenience for the casual listener.

Similarities & Differences


  • Color. The HD 380 and HD 558 are both primarily black.
  • They are both made by Sennheiser, and come in at similar price points, depending on fluctuations within amazon.
  • Both are neutral, although I would say that the 558’s are more so.
  • Both are lightweight and durable.
  • Neither the 558 or 380 are for bass-heads. The 380 is a bit more bass-heavy and places more importance on it overall.


  • Cable. The HD 558 comes with a straight cable while the HD 380s is coiled. Both are replaceable.
  • Type. The HD 380 is closed back while the 558 is open back. The 380s are meant to isolate and block out sound from the outside. The 558’s by contrast are airy, and let the sound leak quite a bit. They are best in an isolated studio environment. People will be able to hear what you’re listening to if you wear them out.
  • Ear-cups. The HD 558 is made of velour and is a lot more comfortable over long periods. The 380s are made of pleather, and are prone to cracking and breaking down over time. Velour is also known for giving you less of a bass response because the cups cushion your ears farther away from the drivers of the headphone.
  • Application. The 558’s do much better with genres like classical and jazz since they have more room to breathe. The sound stage is also a lot better because of the aforementioned open-back moniker. You will start to really get a sense of depth and space. Songs may take on a 3-d image. With gaming, the 558’s are astonishing as well, because of the sound coming in at all angles and directions.

Final Word

If you’re looking for an open back reference can that does exceptionally well with most genres, and remains a joy to listen to, the 558’s are a great option. However, I would actually go with the HD 598’s over them. The frequency range is improved, and the sound is more refined across the spectrum. They also come in a choice of ivory and maroon, or all black. Overall, they are more highly regarded than the 558’s and make an amazing reference point for entry/mid-level enthusiasts. Just be aware that neither is particularly bass-heavy.


If you’re looking for an open back headphone that won’t break the bank, the HD558 is the solution for you. The HD598 is a little better overall, but there’s a trick that you can employ to make the 558’s sound really open up. It’s the foam mod, and it’s very simple. So if you don’t want to pay the price for the 598, but want roughly the same sound, go with the 558. Interested in learning all about them + the foam mod?


By contrast, if you’re looking for the best closed-back reference can, the 380 isn’t your best bet. I have found in my research that the AKG K550 is about the best in this regard. It gives you some elements of an open back while remaining closed, and above all, benefits producers looking for the best mix-down.


Finally, you may not want to pony up the cash for the K550. Understandable. The best option in the true entry-level range would be the MDR V6 in my opinion. It’s pretty much a steal, and will also work as a casual listening headphone. Interested in learning more about it?


Well, that’s about it for today friend! I hope you’ve enjoyed this somewhat long-winded comparison review of the Sennhesier HD 380 vs. HD 558, and came away with some more insight on each.

Convinced that the 598’s are better overall in regard to open back reference? What about the K550? Is that the best closed back reference overall? What do you think about the V6? Let me know!

If you have any other questions, feel I left something out, or just want to reach out, please leave a comment below or Contact me!

I very much look forward to hearing from you..

Until next time… All the best and God bless,





Can’t decide which headphones to purchase? Interested in a complete buyers guide outlining over 40 of the best options on the market? Click on over to the best audiophile headphones to learn more!!

Be sure to also check out my Reviews and Resources page for more helpful and informative articles!


Don't forget to share if you found it helpful!

You may also like


Pablo Rodriguez January 28, 2019 - 3:44 am

Hi Stu! It is a pleasure to read all your reviews! I am Pablo from Argentina, trying to buy my first serious headphones. I reduced my choice to: M50x, HD Sennheiser 380 Pro and Beyerdynamic Custom One Pro, considering my budget and the availability or models in my country. The last two headphones are a little bit more expensive but apparently more comfortable than the M50x. What is your opinion regarding sound quality and confort? Thanks!!

Stuart Charles Black January 29, 2019 - 2:36 am

Hey Pablo!

Thanks much for the vote of confidence my friend 🙂

I think the HD380 is going to be a bit more comfy than a 50x. I’m a bit more forgiving when it comes to comfort though. I used to wear the 50’s at all hours of the night into the wee hours of the morning. As for comfort and the 380 vs. M50x, I would take the 380. It’s got more spacious cups. The 50x almost sits on your head as sort of a cross between Circumaural (Around-Ear) and Supra-Aural (On-Ear).

Unfortunately I haven’t heard the Custom One Pro, but knowing how comfortable other Beyers are and having experience with them, I’d say that’s your best bet as far as comfort goes overall.

It’s hard to recommend one over the other as far as the 50x vs. 380. They both have very similar sound signatures. The 50x improved that kind of metallic treble that was present in the original M50. Will you be doing any mixing or mastering/reference?

Pablo Rodriguez February 1, 2019 - 3:14 am

Hey Stu! Thanks so much for your response! I won’t be doing any mixing at all. I am a software engineer and would like to invest in good headphones for casual listening at the office. For that reason, another aspect I am considering is how easy it is to replace parts, especially living in Argentina. I think that’s a point for M50x, which is the most popular among my candidates. Finally, to avoid having to use an extra pair of headsets for calls, I am also taking a MINOR look at the possibility of using the headphones with a cable that has integrated mic. Well, this is an interesting challenge!

Stuart Charles Black February 5, 2019 - 3:30 am

Hey Pablo!

I think the 50x would be a great choice. You could then opt for something like a V-Moda Boom Pro for taking calls. What do you think?

Thanks so much for stopping by and keep me posted 🙂


Leave a Comment